• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

Betsy Brown Braun

Child Development and Behavior Specialist. Parent Educator. Best Selling Author

  • Home
  • What’s New
    • Upcoming Appearances
    • Video Seminars on Demand
    • In the News
    • Ask BBB – Columns from the Palisadian-Post
  • About
  • Services
    • Register Now
    • Private Consultations
      • Consultation Policies
    • Custody Consultation; Co-Parenting Planning/Implementation
    • Concierge Consulting
    • Parenting Seminars
    • In-Person Parenting Seminars
    • Video Seminars on Demand
    • Parenting Groups
    • Parenting Groups FALL 2022 through MAY 2023
    • Speaker and Seminar Topics
  • Recommendations
    • Betsy’s Books
    • Books Betsy Recommends
    • Special Children’s Books
    • Books: Special Issues
    • Articles
  • Betsyisms
    • Questions and Answers
    • Video Shorts
    • Video Seminars on Demand
    • Well Said
  • Blog
    • All Blog Entries
  • Testimonials
    • Parents
    • Pediatricians/Professionals
  • Media
    • Magazines
    • Television
    • Newspapers
    • Internet
    • Radio
    • Podcasts
    • Electronic Press Kit
  • Contact

What’s Wrong with “I’m Sorry?”

by Betsy Brown Braun on August 27, 2022, under Behavior, Brat-Proofing, Character traits, Child development, Communication, Elementary School Children, Expectations, Parent modeling, Parenting, Peers, Relationships

Years ago, I walked into the 4 year olds’ nursery school classroom and watched Mimi, a fabulous, feisty, third born child, collect all the playdough from the other three children at the table. The three were shocked; one protested loudly. Mimi looked up at me and said,
“Sorry! Sorry! Sorry!”   “Mimi,” I said, “Sorry isn’t enough.”

Every time I hear a parent insist that her child apologize to another, I cringe, and I think about Mimi. Sorry is not enough.

Teaching a child to say I’m sorry is in a category all of its own. While everyone seems to have her own idea of the importance of this act of civility, everyone agrees that it is a crucial part of the manners lesson.   It is important in the big picture. Courts of law make rulings and impose sentences based on the guilty person’s show of remorse and contrition. And it is important in the small picture. Friends make up after a fight when the transgressor expresses his apology.  The woman into whom you accidentally banged your grocery cart, forgives you when you apologize. Saying I’m sorry and genuinely meaning it, owning your misstep,  really can work magic.

Parents teach children to apologize because we want them to learn to be courteous, to be socially appropriate, to show respect, and to demonstrate some accountability for their actions. We also know that learning to say I’m sorry is one of the rules of the game. If you want to have friends and to keep friends, to get along with people, you will need to learn to apologize for your mistakes, missteps, and misdeeds.  But being apologetic is more than mumbling the words, I’m sorry.

Children come to believe that I’m sorry has a magic healing quality. It is supposed to make everything go away, just disappear, to be all better. It’s kind of like a get-out-of-jail-free card.  It can signal the end of an unhappy or uncomfortable episode. Two children in preschool have had a fight.  In their make-up dance, one says to the teacher who is trying to help them solve their problem, “But he didn’t say he was sorry.”  For him I’m sorry is the magic phrase that means everything will be okay, and now things can move on, fair and square.  But what is the transgressor learning?

Children need to be taught that being sorry means something, it is more than saying the words “I’m sorry.”  Their expression of I’m sorry needs to include amends, real efforts at contrition. It cannot be flinging the phrase and running off to play again.  The children who learn this lesson are those who have seen it modeled for them starting at an early age.  I am sorry needs to be modeled and taught as a true expression of remorse and regret.  It is an acknowledgment and a demonstration of accountability. Apologies are about taking responsibility for your action and then making amends. The real I am sorry says, I feel for you. I regret having done what I did because of the way it affected you. And that is on me.

Then there is the parent who insists that his child say “I’m sorry” to her sibling or to a playmate when, in reality, the child isn’t sorry at all. It is the parent, you see, who feels embarrassed or uncomfortable about what his child has done. He feels social pressure to make the child play by the rules and apologize. If the child doesn’t, then he is a bad parent. Actually, by in insisting that the child say he is sorry, the parent is teaching the child to lie. Very often the child isn’t sorry at all. She absolutely meant to grab the toy from her brother, hit her friend, tear up her playmate’s picture, t rip her classmate. She is not sorry!  But Dad says she has to say she is sorry. Sometimes the child is asked to say she is sorry before she really knows what happened and what her part in the action was. The child might not even know what she is sorry about, and she is just parroting what her parent says.  I am not at all sure that is a lesson you want to teach your child.

Perfunctory apologies don’t work for a lot of reasons. First of all, they are hard. Little Mimi was trying to get closure, she wanted to make the whole thing just go away. She was not remorseful. She wanted all that playdough. Sometimes to a child, the apology feels like he is losing, and that feels bad.  No one likes to admit he is wrong, and the child may feel ashamed.  A forced apology, begrudgingly given, is ineffective for the transgressor because the child is likely still experiencing the emotion that drove him to his misdeed. To top it off, the forced apology usually does not even address the situation or the behavior.  When children learn that an apology includes a show of contrition, the needs of the wronged person take precedence. Whether the child feels sorry or not, he is still considering the victim.

When starting at a very early age parents introduce an apology as something more than a forced phrase to parrot, apologies add to the child’s development of empathy and understanding. When  I’m sorry  is accompanied by a show of contrition, by making amends, it will become an effective, life long, highly effective and meaningful skill in a person’s forever social skills tool box.

Here are a few tips for turning around the I’m sorry ship.

 

  • Know that teaching sincere apologizing is fueled by and fuels the child’s developing empathy.
  • Model apologizing deliberately  by making amends to your spouse, your sister, your friends, all within earshot of your child.
  • With two children, wait until everyone has calmed down (including you!) before facilitating the apology piece. The apology conversation should not reflect your emotions, including anger.
  • Be sure to give both the victim and the transgressor a chance to share the what and why. Part of empathy is paying attention to how others feel.  All players need to feel heard, and it will release the child’s need to “stick to his guns,” unable to relate to his victim or accept responsibility for his behavior.
  • Know that children’s apologies may not be spontaneous. A child may need to be encouraged to tune into how the victim is feeling, and she may need suggestions as to what might make that child feel better.
  • Making amends and acts of contrition are more effective than I’m sorry. Try not to focus on the words.  Making amends helps the victim to feel better and is reparative to the relationship in a way that words are not. (Suggestions for acts of contrition:  get an ice pack, bring the child his “Lovie,” help him repair or build his project; do the child’s chores for him;  give the child your turn or your place in line,   The victim needs to experience the transgressor’s effort.)
  • Praise your child for his n spontaneous or prompted shows of contrition, pointing out how much better the victim must feel.

: " Forcing a child to say he's sorry; making a child say he's sorry, asking for apologies, chidlren's apologies, I'm sorry; making a child apologize, saying "Im sorry, teacing contrition; making amends;
Leave a Comment

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to receive news, articles and blogs from Betsy

Betsy is our modern-day version of the ‘village elder’ from whom we all seek counsel. Her suggestions have enabled me to respond to my children’s questions and curiosity in a way that respects their intelligence without confusing them.

- Paulina Ladreyt, mother of twin boys, Santa Monica, CA
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:30:37+00:00
Betsy is our modern-day version of the ‘village elder’ from whom we all seek counsel. Her suggestions have enabled me to respond to my children’s questions and curiosity in a way that respects their intelligence without confusing them. - Paulina Ladreyt, mother of twin boys, Santa Monica, CA
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5305/

Betsy Brown Braun’s class has been an incredible experience for me. Her wisdom, combined with a rare and wonderful sense of humor, has helped me become a better parent.

- Deborah Gleiberman, mother of three children
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:31:05+00:00
Betsy Brown Braun’s class has been an incredible experience for me. Her wisdom, combined with a rare and wonderful sense of humor, has helped me become a better parent. - Deborah Gleiberman, mother of three children
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5306/

Betsy is a wise, humorous, and caring advisor... Due in large part to Betsy, we are smarter parents and our children are happier and healthier as a result.

- Steven Webber, father of two boys
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:31:24+00:00
Betsy is a wise, humorous, and caring advisor... Due in large part to Betsy, we are smarter parents and our children are happier and healthier as a result. - Steven Webber, father of two boys
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5307/

Betsy Brown Braun is a master teacher and one of the wisest parenting experts I have ever known.

- Steven Carr Reuben, Ph.D., author of Children of Character
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:32:54+00:00
Betsy Brown Braun is a master teacher and one of the wisest parenting experts I have ever known. - Steven Carr Reuben, Ph.D., author of Children of Character
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5308/

Betsy is always able to come up with simple and unique approaches to common parenting problems as well as more complex issues. What she says makes good sense and always works...

- Joanna VanTrees Cowitt, mother of a boy and a girl, Los Angeles, CA
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:33:11+00:00
Betsy is always able to come up with simple and unique approaches to common parenting problems as well as more complex issues. What she says makes good sense and always works... - Joanna VanTrees Cowitt, mother of a boy and a girl, Los Angeles, CA
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5309/

I love the way you think and how clear you make the issues seem. You are so brilliant and I love how perceptive and straightforward you are. You anchor me and the things you say make a lot of sense.

- Leigh Nickoll, Marriage and Family Counselor
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:33:31+00:00
I love the way you think and how clear you make the issues seem. You are so brilliant and I love how perceptive and straightforward you are. You anchor me and the things you say make a lot of sense. - Leigh Nickoll, Marriage and Family Counselor
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5310/

Betsy’s private consultations are fabulous. She has a gift for understanding all different types of children and giving advice that works for your particular child.

- Craig Mallery
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:33:55+00:00
Betsy’s private consultations are fabulous. She has a gift for understanding all different types of children and giving advice that works for your particular child. - Craig Mallery
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5311/

Betsy got me over the bumps of raising two young boys and over the moguls of raising teenage boys. She is my rock.

- Deidra Hall
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:34:15+00:00
Betsy got me over the bumps of raising two young boys and over the moguls of raising teenage boys. She is my rock. - Deidra Hall
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5312/

Your talk really helped me in becoming a more “open” parent and less worried about little things that really don’t matter and restrict kids in a negative way.

- Nina Hong, mother
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:34:35+00:00
Your talk really helped me in becoming a more “open” parent and less worried about little things that really don’t matter and restrict kids in a negative way. - Nina Hong, mother
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5313/

Betsy keeps it real. She respects parents and children and gives parents the straight scoop about productive communication. I turn to her insights again and again.

- Alexis Bircoll Martin, mother of two
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:34:56+00:00
Betsy keeps it real. She respects parents and children and gives parents the straight scoop about productive communication. I turn to her insights again and again. - Alexis Bircoll Martin, mother of two
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5314/

Betsy Brown Braun is a fine observer of children…

- Dr. Robert M. Landaw, Pediatrician
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:35:16+00:00
Betsy Brown Braun is a fine observer of children… - Dr. Robert M. Landaw, Pediatrician
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5315/

Betsy offers the clearest, calming, and most helpful advice there is on parenting...She's like having the smartest, coolest, and amazingly right mom just a phone call away.

- Jane Buckingham, Author of The Modern Girls Guide to Life and The Modern Girls Guide to Motherhood
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:35:37+00:00
Betsy offers the clearest, calming, and most helpful advice there is on parenting...She's like having the smartest, coolest, and amazingly right mom just a phone call away. - Jane Buckingham, Author of The Modern Girls Guide to Life and The Modern Girls Guide to Motherhood
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5316/

A parenting guru.

- The New York Times
Betsy Brown Braun
2019-06-21T14:35:55+00:00
A parenting guru. - The New York Times
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5317/

We’ve been overwhelmed by the outpouring of positive response in our community from the PA Forum Betsy held for our Middle and High School parents. We are all discussing our implementation of her practical, meaningful advice - from how to respond to our teen's and tween’s meltdowns to how to deal with their messy rooms. Additionally she helped frame parenting (and over-parenting) during this challenging time as well as normalize our parental anxieties.Thank you Betsy!

- Leigh Morales, MS PA Forum Chair, The Greenhill School, Dallas TX
Betsy Brown Braun
2021-03-09T19:10:44+00:00
We’ve been overwhelmed by the outpouring of positive response in our community from the PA Forum Betsy held for our Middle and High School parents. We are all discussing our implementation of her practical, meaningful advice - from how to respond to our teen's and tween’s meltdowns to how to deal with their messy rooms. Additionally she helped frame parenting (and over-parenting) during this challenging time as well as normalize our parental anxieties.Thank you Betsy! - Leigh Morales, MS PA Forum Chair, The Greenhill School, Dallas TX
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5701/

Your voice is so often in my head as I navigate the adventures (good, bad, and yes, sometimes ugly) of parenting. I can’t imagine what I would have done all these years without it...it’s like a touchstone that keeps me on track

- Thea Andrews Wolf, mom of 2 middle school boys
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-02-03T07:33:32+00:00
Your voice is so often in my head as I navigate the adventures (good, bad, and yes, sometimes ugly) of parenting. I can’t imagine what I would have done all these years without it...it’s like a touchstone that keeps me on track - Thea Andrews Wolf, mom of 2 middle school boys
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5830/

You’re like a drug and it’s hard to get enough of your wisdom so thank you!

-Maryam Shahrokhi, Pediatrician in LA
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-03-01T09:52:11+00:00
You’re like a drug and it’s hard to get enough of your wisdom so thank you! -Maryam Shahrokhi, Pediatrician in LA
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5861/

Betsy is quite simply pure magic. Through the ups and downs of parenting (and life!), she is a constant source of tremendous guidance and wisdom and comfort. Having Betsy as a trusted resource (who has literally seen it all) as I navigate life with two boys is truly a blessing.

-Rebecca Jonah, mother of two boys
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-06-30T10:31:43+00:00
Betsy is quite simply pure magic. Through the ups and downs of parenting (and life!), she is a constant source of tremendous guidance and wisdom and comfort. Having Betsy as a trusted resource (who has literally seen it all) as I navigate life with two boys is truly a blessing. -Rebecca Jonah, mother of two boys
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5916/

I have participated in Betsy’s groups and private consultations over the past decade-plus. I find her guidance to be experience and research-based. And I respond to her no-bullshit directness. Her support helps me feel like I am working to be the best mom I can be; knowledgeable, present, and open. Being in the groups has given me so much confidence as a parent, plus camaraderie and lifelong friends with my fellow mom members. Betsy is the rock, sounding board, expert, and friend everyone needs while navigating the parenting journey.

-Meredith Alexander, mother of two boys
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-07-01T07:21:18+00:00
I have participated in Betsy’s groups and private consultations over the past decade-plus. I find her guidance to be experience and research-based. And I respond to her no-bullshit directness. Her support helps me feel like I am working to be the best mom I can be; knowledgeable, present, and open. Being in the groups has given me so much confidence as a parent, plus camaraderie and lifelong friends with my fellow mom members. Betsy is the rock, sounding board, expert, and friend everyone needs while navigating the parenting journey. -Meredith Alexander, mother of two boys
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5919/

Betsy is quite simply pure magic. Through the ups and downs of parenting, she is a constant source of tremendous guidance, , wisdom, and comfort. Having Betsy as a trusted resource, as I navigate life with two boys, is truly a blessing.

-Rebecca Jonah, mother of two boys
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-07-01T07:21:36+00:00
Betsy is quite simply pure magic. Through the ups and downs of parenting, she is a constant source of tremendous guidance, , wisdom, and comfort. Having Betsy as a trusted resource, as I navigate life with two boys, is truly a blessing. -Rebecca Jonah, mother of two boys
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5920/

My wife and I watched your Discipline Video last night . It was ENORMOUSLY helpful...45 years of wisdom in 45 minutes!

-Brian Goldsmith, father of two young children
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-09-26T09:15:16+00:00
My wife and I watched your Discipline Video last night . It was ENORMOUSLY helpful...45 years of wisdom in 45 minutes! -Brian Goldsmith, father of two young children
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5993/

When you [Betsy] speak, everything just sort of clicks and all the chaos going on around us seems to have order once again. We really appreciate your help and insight.

-Carter Horton Thomas, father of two girls
Betsy Brown Braun
2022-07-26T16:57:10+00:00
When you [Betsy] speak, everything just sort of clicks and all the chaos going on around us seems to have order once again. We really appreciate your help and insight. -Carter Horton Thomas, father of two girls
https://betsybrownbraun.com/testimonials/5969/
0
Betsy Brown Braun

Betsy Brown Braun Follow

Child development & behavior specialist, best selling author of award winning Just Tell Me What to Say (2008) & You're Not the Boss of Me. (2010)

BetsyBBraun
betsybbraun Betsy Brown Braun @betsybbraun ·
28 Aug

What’s wrong with “I’m sorry?” https://betsybrownbraun.com/2022/08/27/whats -wrong-with-im-sorry/

Reply on Twitter 1564000394694389762 Retweet on Twitter 1564000394694389762 Like on Twitter 1564000394694389762 Twitter 1564000394694389762
Load More

Secondary Sidebar

Seminars, groups and consulting
Engagements, media, presentations, and video seminars
Just Tell Me What to Say and You’re Not The Boss of Me. Buy them today!
On Demand Parenting Seminars.
Read the latest blog posts from Betsy.

Betsy Brown Braun

  • Home
  • What’s New
  • About
  • Services
  • Recommendations
  • Betsyisms
  • Blog
  • Testimonials
  • Media
  • Contact